Loanio

Question -

Because of the credit crunch, is this a good time to consider borrowing against a 401(k) savings as a means of paying off other loans? My current 401(k) planning investment return is 5 percent, and the interest I will be paying on it is 9 percent.

To borrow or not borrow against a 401K.

Answer -

If you only really consider the numbers in the situation, taking out a loan against your 401(k) in order to pay off a high interest credit card or some other higher interest debt may seem like a no brainer decision. This is because you would be paying yourself back the interest by paying back a 401(k) loan, but with credit card debt or a high interest loan you would be paying as much as 15 percent or more straight to the bank. Plus in today’s market, the 9 percent that you speak of is more than you would make if you were just keeping the money to sit in your account.

With that said, however, most 401k planning experts would shudder at the mere idea of raiding tomorrow’s intended nest egg to fund the financial indiscretions of today. This kind of thing may work out in terms of pure numbers, experts will gladly agree, but that does not make this a good idea, or even one worth putting consideration into. Financial planners generally agree that there are a number of concerns to touch on before you ever make a decision as large as this one, for example:

What if you leave your company?

If you leave your company for any reason at all, you generally only have 30 days to pay back the entire loan in full; otherwise you will have to pay ordinary income taxes on the withdrawal along with a 10-percent IRS penalty, assuming you are under the age of 59 and a half.

The bottom line here is that this is a pretty foolish move in most if not all situations, even if you are desperate to pay off a high interest credit card or some other high interest debt that has been accrued. If you are likely to rack up more debt in the process, have concerns relating to job security, or are paying off loans that are tax deductible or low interest, then this is definitely a foolish way to go. On the other hand, there are scenarios where this could allow you to come out financially ahead, but they tend to be few and far between. If you’re not sure, then it would be wise to sit down with an investment advisor or financial advisor who can help you weigh your options.

Before you take out any loan you should sit down with an expert that can help you review your choices. You just may discover that there is a better, less risky and less costly option that you have not yet explored for this particular situation.

Photo Credits: 1

Originally posted 2008-11-10 20:58:13. Republished by Blog Post Promoter

• 401k Planning Most people have questions when it comes to 401k planning and retirement. These people often wonder what 401k planning is, how 401k planning works, and how a dwindling balance can be revived. 401k plans can be complex, but they can also be quite easy to understand with a little bit......
• Stocks are a Great Investment /caption] Most people recognize that stocks are an excellent investment, but purchasing stocks can be a confusing process. This is especially true if you have little experience in investing, or no experience at all. You can turn the stock buying process into a good investment even as a beginner, and......
• Prepare for Your Retirement Now /caption] If you are young and just beginning a career, then the concept of retirement planning may seem so far away that it is the last thing that you put any consideration into. However if you are on the opposite end of the fence and retirement is just around the......
• 401K Planning 101 If you are young, and you are just beginning a career, then the idea of retirement planning may seem so very far off that it is probably the last thing on your mind right now. But if you are on the other side of the fence, and retirement is approaching......
• How Do I Plan For Retirement? One of the most common questions people have is how do I plan for retirement? Whether you’re looking at retiring in five years or thirty five, it is important to come up with a plan that will provide you with more than enough to live comfortably. It is no longer......

• Good Debt, Bad Debt and Flawed Investment Return Data I can't tell you how often I hear or read someone argue that they have "good debt."   This "good debt"  argument is made to rationalize having a car loan, a HELOC or second mortgage balance, and even credit card debt.  The argument goes something like this:  "The money I have borrowed......
• UnderAppreciated Listings RSS Feed Update I started my RSS feeds on March 18th...  I thought I would check in on my favorite (Underappreciated Listings)...  There have been 6,364 listings profiled, requesting to borrower $61,781,819 or $9,952.01 per loan on average. Here is the listing status break down... Status Total Amount Number Per Loan Cancelled $3,427,672......
• Turning Japanese Here's some interesting info from Bill Bonner, author of Empire of Debt: The Rise of an Epic Financial Crisis The Fed is still talking about the risk of inflation...while the risk of deflation rises daily. Deflation happens when liquidity dries up. Suddenly, money disappears. Lenders don’t lend. Spenders don’t spend.......
• Credit Card Debt Consolidation Options Credit cards have been up to some nasty tricks lately.  They are raising interest rates with only a subtle notice, and cutting credit lines with no notice.  Angry consumers are looking for ways to consolidate their debt.  I have had some first-hand experience with both scenarios, which led to me......
• Pay Off Highest Interest Or Highest Balance Credit Card - Analysis Paralysis The question comes up all the time when a person wants to start getting their credit cards under control - Pay off the cards with the highest interest or the cards with the highest balance? On the one and you have high interest cards - A high interest rate costs......